Known Discount Conflicts
Last updated on November 20, 2026
💡 For more frequently asked questions about our Upsell Builder app and its upsell offers, you may refer here: Upsell Builder FAQs
Vitals Upsell Builder discounts are applied at checkout as Shopify automatic discounts. If a discount doesn't show at checkout, check these common causes:
1. Another discount can't combine with Vitals
Shopify only applies discounts together when their combination settings allow it. In Vitals, open any discount offer and check Discount combinations at the bottom of the discount card: it sets which other discounts (product, order and shipping discounts) your offers can combine with, for all your offers. All three boxes are ticked by default. Keep the box that matches your discount code ticked: for example, Order discounts (on the cart subtotal) must stay ticked for order discount codes to combine with Vitals discounts. For your own discount codes, automatic discounts and other apps' discounts, open them in Shopify admin > Discounts and allow them to combine with product discounts (and order discounts if you use a Spending Goal). For example, to combine a Shopify automatic discount on products or collections with a Vitals Gift offer, turn on Product discounts (on cart items) in Vitals and Product discounts in the Shopify discount's Combinations.
If you don't want a Shopify discount to combine with your Vitals offers, open it in Shopify admin > Discounts and, under Combinations, untick Product discounts (for a Spending Goal, untick Order discounts instead). When two discounts can't combine, Shopify applies the one that gives the best price. Confirm the result with a test order.
Vitals offers can't link to or reuse an existing Shopify discount. If you choose No discount as an offer's reward, the offer only suggests products and creates no Shopify discount; your existing automatic discount continues to apply according to its own conditions.
Combination settings alone don't guarantee that discounts will apply together. Check the target items, quantities, customer eligibility, dates, usage limits and store eligibility, then test the combination at checkout in an incognito window.
Shoppers can enter up to five product or order discount codes and one shipping discount code on the same order, as long as the discounts are allowed to combine. To combine two order discount codes, turn on Order discounts under Combinations for each code; allowing product discounts alone doesn't cover this. To combine more than one product discount on the same item, your store must be on the Shopify Plus plan.
2. Gift-offer progress and checkout use different totals
For Gift offers, the widget's progress normally counts qualifying items after product discounts, while checkout evaluates the gift discount at full price. This can make the progress shown in the widget differ from the total evaluated at checkout.
3. Bundle or Buy X Get Y items were added to the cart separately
Product Bundle and Buy X Get Y discounts apply when the shopper adds the offer through its widget. If the products are added to the cart one by one, the discount isn't applied, except for a Buy X Get Y offer with Discount the cheapest item automatically ticked. See Understanding How Vitals Upsell Offers Now Work with Shopify Functions.
If a Buy X Get Y offer has Require the same variant ticked under Discounts, the bought units and the reward must all be the same variant, so units of different variants don't count together. With Discount the cheapest item automatically also ticked, each variant is counted separately.
4. The Vitals automatic discount was deleted
If a [DO NOT DELETE] Vitals Automatic Discount was deleted in Shopify admin, offers can still show on your store while their discount isn't applied. Publish the affected offers again to restore it. See Understanding How Vitals Upsell Offers Now Work with Shopify Functions.
5. A Volume Discount add-on uses Fixed price
For a Volume Discount tier add-on, Fixed price can appear correctly in the widget but the add-on may be charged at its full price at checkout. Use Amount off or Percentage off instead, with a value that gives the same final price. Publish the offer, add the item through the widget and check the cart price. Fixed price on the Volume Discount tier itself works as expected.
6. A custom checkout is used
Vitals discounts work with the standard Shopify checkout. Apps that replace Shopify's checkout with their own may not apply them. Please use the standard Shopify checkout.
7. The shopper chose a subscription
Upsell Builder discounts don't apply to subscription purchases. Eligible one-time purchases still get the discount.
If you've checked these and orders still come through without a discount, please contact our support team so we can investigate.
Still stuck?
Chat with our support team, we'll sort it out with you.